Deepen the defoaming field, assist in efficient production, and provide one-stop foam solutions
Common Types of Defoamers
Release Date:
2020-06-15
During industrial production, numerous harmful foams are generated, necessitating the addition of defoamers. There are many types of defoamers, including organosilicon compounds, polyethers, silicone–ether grafts, and those containing amines, imines, and amides. These defoamers typically exhibit faster defoaming action, longer foam‑suppressing duration, and broader compatibility with various media, even under harsh conditions such as high temperatures, strong acids, and strong alkalis. They are widely used to eliminate unwanted foam in processes across industries like latex production, textile sizing, food fermentation, biopharmaceuticals, coatings, petrochemicals, papermaking, and industrial cleaning. 1. Natural Oils (e.g., soybean oil, corn oil) Advantages: readily available, low cost, and easy to use. Disadvantages: if improperly stored, they can deteriorate, leading to an increase in acid value. 2. Higher Alcohols Higher alcohols are linear molecules with strong hydrophobicity and weak hydrophilicity, making them effective defoamers in aqueous systems. In the early 1970s, Soviet researchers conducted experiments in aqueous solutions of anionic, cationic, and nonionic surfactants, demonstrating that the defoaming efficacy of alcohols correlates with their solubility and diffusion rate within the foaming liquid. Alcohols with carbon chain lengths of C7–C9 are the most effective. Higher alcohols ranging from C12 to C22, when formulated into water-in-oil emulsions with appropriate emulsifiers—typically at particle sizes of 4–9 μm and concentrations of 20–50%—serve as efficient defoamers for aqueous systems. Additionally, certain esterified derivatives, such as phenethyl oleate and phenethyl laurate, exhibit defoaming properties in penicillin fermentation; the latter can also function as a precursor. 3. Polyether Defoamers A wide variety of polyether-based defoamers exist, including: a. GP‑type defoamers: These are synthesized by adding propylene oxide or a mixture of ethylene oxide and propylene oxide to glycerol as the starting agent. Due to their poor hydrophilicity and limited solubility in foaming media, GP‑type defoamers are best suited for dilute fermentation broths. Their superior foam‑suppressing capability makes them ideal for incorporation into basal media to curb foam formation throughout the entire fermentation process. b. GPE‑type defoamers: Also known as “foam killers,” these are produced by further adding ethylene oxide to the terminal polypropylene glycol chains of GP‑type defoamers, yielding polyoxyethylene‑polyoxypropylene glycerols with hydrophilic end groups. Depending on the degree of ethylene oxide addition—10%, 20%, … up to 50%—they are designated as GPE10, GPE20, … GPE50. GPE‑type defoamers possess better hydrophilicity, spread easily in foaming media, and demonstrate strong defoaming power; however, their higher solubility results in shorter active durations, making them more effective in viscous fermentation broths. c. GPES‑type defoamers: A newer class of polyether defoamers features hydrophobic stearate end groups on the GPE‑type polymer chains, creating a block copolymer structure with hydrophobic ends separated by hydrophilic segments. This molecular architecture facilitates flat, layered aggregation at the gas–liquid interface, enhancing surface activity and improving defoaming efficiency. 4. Silicone‑Based Defoamers The most commonly used is polydimethylsiloxane, also referred to as dimethyl silicone oil. It exhibits low surface energy and surface tension, with limited solubility in water and most oils yet high activity. Its backbone consists of siloxane linkages, rendering it a nonpolar molecule. It shows poor affinity for polar solvents like water and minimal compatibility with common oils. With low volatility and chemical inertness, it is relatively stable and exhibits low toxicity. Pure polydimethylsiloxane, without dispersion treatment, is difficult to employ as a defoamer, likely due to its high interfacial tension with water and low spreading coefficient, hindering uniform distribution in foaming media. Therefore, silicone oil is often blended with SiO₂ aerosols to form composite materials—specifically, dispersing treated SiO₂ aerosols into dimethyl silicone oil and subjecting the mixture to controlled temperature and time treatments to produce a usable defoamer. Organic silicon defoamers are prepared by mechanically emulsifying silicone grease, emulsifiers, water repellents, thickeners, and other ingredients with an appropriate amount of water. They are characterized by low surface tension, high surface activity, strong defoaming power, minimal dosage requirements, and low cost. They are immiscible with water and most organic substances, effectively suppressing foam across a wide range of media. They also offer excellent thermal stability, functioning reliably over a broad temperature range of 5°C to 150°C, and good chemical stability, resisting reactions with other substances. With proper formulation, they can be used in acidic, alkaline, or saline solutions without compromising product quality. Furthermore, they display physiological inertness, with an LD50 of 250 g/kg in rodents, making them suitable for food and pharmaceutical applications. Capable of both suppressing and breaking foam, they fall under the category of broad-spectrum defoamers. They are extensively employed in detergents, papermaking, pulp processing, sugar refining, electroplating, fertilizer production, auxiliary agents, and wastewater treatment. In the petroleum industry, they are widely utilized for desulfurization of natural gas and accelerating oil–gas separation, as well as for controlling or suppressing foam in equipment involved in ethylene glycol drying, aromatic hydrocarbon extraction, asphalt processing, and lubricant dewaxing. In the textile sector, they aid in defoaming during dyeing, scouring, and sizing processes; in the chemical industry, they serve to suppress foam in resin synthesis, latex production, coating, and ink manufacturing; and in the food industry, they help manage foam in various concentration, fermentation, and distillation operations. Silicone grease can be applied directly to pot walls, outlets, or metal screens for defoaming purposes. Alternatively, it can be formulated into solutions for oil-phase defoaming, or mixed with low-viscosity silicone oil to create water-in-oil emulsions suitable for multiple aqueous systems. In medicine, it is frequently used preoperatively and before X-ray or gastroscopic examinations to relieve abdominal bloating or gastric distension. Defoamers can generally be categorized into two types: those that eliminate existing foam, such as ethanol; and those that inhibit foam formation, such as emulsified silicone oil. In China, approved defoamers include emulsified silicone oil, higher alcohol–fatty acid ester complexes, polyoxyethylene–polyoxypropylene pentaerythritol ethers, polyoxyethylene–polyoxypropylene amine ethers, polyoxypropylene glycerol ethers, and polyoxypropylene compounds. 5. Polyether‑Modified Silicon Combining the advantages of polyethers and organic silicon defoamers, this product is non‑toxic, harmless to microbial strains, requires only minimal addition, and offers excellent cost‑effectiveness.
During industrial production, numerous harmful foams are generated, necessitating the addition of defoamers. A wide variety of defoamers are available, including organosilicones, polyethers, silicone–ether grafts, and compounds containing amines, imines, and amides. These formulations exhibit faster defoaming rates, longer foam‑suppression durations, and broader compatibility with diverse media, even under harsh conditions such as high temperatures, strong acids, and strong alkalis. They are extensively used to eliminate undesirable foams in processes across industries including latex production, textile sizing, food fermentation, biopharmaceuticals, coatings, petrochemicals, papermaking, and industrial cleaning.
1. Natural oils (such as soybean oil, corn oil, etc.)
Advantages: easy to obtain, low cost, and simple to use.
Disadvantages: If improperly stored, it is prone to spoilage, leading to an increase in acid value.
2. Higher alcohols: Higher alcohols are linear molecules with strong hydrophobic and weak hydrophilic characteristics, making them effective defoamers in aqueous systems. In the early 1970s, Soviet researchers conducted experiments in aqueous solutions of anionic, cationic, and nonionic surfactants and proposed that the defoaming efficacy of alcohols is related to their solubility and diffusion rate in the foaming liquid. Alcohols with carbon chain lengths of C7 to C9 are particularly effective as defoamers.
High‑carbon alcohols with carbon chain lengths of C12 to C22, formulated with an appropriate emulsifier into a water-in-oil emulsion having a particle size of 4–9 μm and a concentration of 20–50%, serve as defoamers in aqueous systems.
There are also esters, such as phenethyl oleate and phenylacetic lauryl ester, which exhibit defoaming activity in penicillin fermentation; the latter can further serve as a precursor.
3. Polyether-based defoamers
There are quite a few types, mainly the following:
a. GP-type defoamers are prepared by adding propylene oxide, or a mixture of ethylene oxide and propylene oxide, to glycerol as the initiator, followed by addition polymerization.
GP-type defoamers have poor hydrophilicity and low solubility in foaming media, making them suitable for use in dilute fermentation broths. Their foam‑suppressing efficacy surpasses their defoaming performance, so they are best added to the basal medium to inhibit foam formation throughout the entire fermentation process.
b. GPE-type defoamers, such as PaoDi, are produced by further adding ethylene oxide to the polypropylene glycol chain ends of GP-type defoamers, resulting in a polyoxyethylene–polyoxypropylene glycerol with hydrophilic end groups; they are also referred to as such. Depending on the degree of ethylene oxide addition—10%, 20%, … 50%—they are designated GPE10, GPE20, … GPE50, respectively.
GPE-type defoamers exhibit good hydrophilicity, readily spread in foaming media, and possess strong defoaming performance; however, they also have relatively high solubility and a short duration of active defoaming efficacy, making them particularly effective when used in viscous fermentation broths.
c. GPES-type defoamer: A new class of polyether-based defoamers is available, in which the chain ends of GPE-type defoamers are capped with hydrophobic stearate groups, resulting in a block copolymer structure with hydrophobic chains at both termini and a hydrophilic segment in between. Molecules with this architecture readily adsorb at the gas–liquid interface in a planar, lying‑down configuration, thereby exhibiting strong surface activity and high defoaming efficiency.
4. Silicon-based
The commonly used substance is polydimethylsiloxane, also known as dimethyl silicone oil. It has low surface energy and surface tension, exhibits poor solubility in water and most common oils, and possesses high activity. Its backbone consists of siloxane linkages, making it a nonpolar molecule. It is incompatible with polar solvents such as water and shows very limited affinity for ordinary oils. With low volatility and chemical inertness, it is relatively stable and exhibits low toxicity. Pure polydimethylsiloxane, without prior dispersion, is difficult to use as an antifoaming agent, likely because its high interfacial tension with water and low spreading coefficient make it challenging to disperse within the foaming medium. Therefore, by blending silicone oil with SiO2 aerosol—specifically, incorporating hydrophobically treated SiO2 aerosol into dimethyl silicone oil and subjecting the mixture to controlled temperature and time conditions—a suitable antifoaming formulation can be prepared.
Silicone antifoams are formulated by mechanically emulsifying silicone oil, emulsifiers, water-repellent agents, thickeners, and an appropriate amount of water. They are characterized by low surface tension, high surface activity, strong defoaming performance, minimal dosage requirements, and low cost. These products are immiscible with water and most organic substances, effectively suppressing foam in a wide range of gaseous media. They exhibit excellent thermal stability, making them suitable for use across a broad temperature range of 5°C to 150°C; they also demonstrate good chemical stability, resisting reactions with other compounds, and—when properly formulated—can be employed in acidic, alkaline, or saline solutions without compromising product quality. Furthermore, they possess physiological inertness, with an LD50 of 250 g/kg in rodents, and are commonly used in the food and pharmaceutical industries. Capable of both inhibiting and breaking foam, they fall into the category of broad-spectrum antifoams. They are extensively applied in industrial processes such as detergents, papermaking, pulp production, sugar refining, electroplating, fertilizer manufacturing, auxiliary agent formulation, and wastewater treatment to control foam. In the petroleum industry, they are widely utilized for desulfurization of natural gas and to accelerate oil–gas separation; they are also employed in equipment for ethylene glycol drying, aromatic hydrocarbon extraction, asphalt processing, and lubricant dewaxing to manage or suppress foam. In the textile industry, they serve to eliminate foam during dyeing, scouring, and sizing operations; in the chemical industry, they are used to control foam in resin synthesis, latex production, coating formulations, and ink manufacturing; and in the food industry, they help mitigate foam in various concentration, fermentation, and distillation processes. Silicone oil can be applied directly to pot walls, discharge outlets, or metal screens to achieve defoaming. When formulated into solutions, it is effective for defoaming in oil-based systems. Mixing silicone oil with low-viscosity silicone fluid to create water-in-oil emulsions enables its use in numerous aqueous systems. In medicine, it is routinely employed preoperatively and prior to X-ray or endoscopic examinations to remove intestinal or gastric gas.
Defoamers can generally be classified into two types: one type eliminates existing bubbles, such as ethanol; the other type inhibits bubble formation, such as emulsified silicone oil. In China, the defoamers approved for use include emulsified silicone oil, high‑carbon alcohol fatty acid ester complexes, polyoxyethylene–polyoxypropylene pentaerythritol ethers, polyoxyethylene–polyoxypropylene amine ethers, polyoxypropylene glycerol ethers, and polyoxypropylene…
5. Polyether-modified silicone
It combines the advantages of both polyether and silicone defoamers, is non‑toxic and harmless, poses no harm to microbial strains, requires only a very small dosage, and is a highly cost‑effective product.
Next page
Next page